Is This September Report the October Surprise? 

The September jobs report was surprisingly strong, as the U.S. economy added 254,000 net new jobs, far higher than forecasts.

News

We have expanded our reporting to cover Canada and the UK.

recruitonomics

Recruitonomics is a hub for data-driven research that aims to make sense of our evolving world of work.

UAW Taps the Brake on Speedy Job Growth

Author: Andrew Flowers
 and Liz Anderson
03 Nov 23

After months of strike activity making little splash in employment numbers, labor disputes in the auto manufacturing sector impacted job growth in October.

In October, the U.S. economy added 150,000 jobs. The unemployment rate rose slightly to 3.9%. Paired with revisions to last month’s numbers, this report shows the labor market is cooling ever so slightly, right on cue. 

However, it isn’t exactly the organic cooling the Fed was looking for. The most striking part of this report was the decline in manufacturing: Labor action in the motor vehicle and parts manufacturing subsector dropped by 33,000 last month. The United Auto Workers and American auto manufacturers recently came to a deal but not before the strikes disrupted strong employment growth. 

Pumping the brakes, but just to the speed limit 

The growth this month was cooler than market expectations. After a surprise uptick in employment growth last month (which was revised down by 39,000 in today’s report), this growth aligns more with the Federal Reserve’s hopes for the labor market: Not nearly recessionary but less strong than the rip-roaring rates seen in 2021 and 2022. 

Chart showing monthly net change in nonfarm payrolls in the United States since September 2021.

The unemployment rate ticked up ever so slightly, to 3.9%. Historically low, this rate continues a streak of under-4% employment, going on its 23rd month. The labor market remains tight, even as it cools. 

Chart showing the unemployment rate from 1950 on, with a second layer showing how many consecutive months the rate has been below 4%.

Both the prime-age labor force participation rate and the employment to population ratio dipped slightly from the previous month, to 83.3% and 80.6%, respectively. 

Chart representing prime-age (25-54 year olds) labor force participation rate from 2020 to today.

Wage growth cruises down

Wage growth – average hourly earnings (for private sector non-managers) – continues to moderate; over the last 3- and 12-months down to 3.5% and 4.4% annual rates, respectively. That said, October’s monthly reading was a little hot at 4.2%, but the broader trend should assuage the Fed’s fears of inflation picking back up after a period of cooling, the likes of what we saw in the summer of 2022.

Chart showing average hourly earnings of private production and non-supervisory employees, annualized percent change, from 2020 to today.

The summer (ahem, year) of strikes makes a dent

Manufacturing was weighed down by the UAW strike, which caused a decline of 33,000 jobs. Though striking workers are not counted as unemployed, the strikes against American manufacturers last month made a dent in employment growth in the sector. 

Elsewhere in the report, sector gains were as expected: Healthcare continues to grow strongly (+58,000), information (aka, technology) declined slightly (-9,000), and transportation and warehousing decreased as expected (-12,000).

Leisure and hospitality had a disappointing month after impressive gains in September. The sector added just 19,000 jobs in October, compared to 74,000 last month. The jump may have just been a blip, as employment growth has slowed in the sector all year.

What does this mean for recruiters? 

It was another positive jobs report for recruiters! Cooler labor growth may sound bad but in reality, it just means there’s a sustainable pace of growth that recruiters can feel more comfortable with. The participation rate did decline, yes, but remains high – there’s a larger pool of workers to recruit from. The strike activity reminds us how much disruption can be created during a time of increased worker power.

Chief Economist
Liz Anderson – Recruitonomics
Economics Writer

Sign up to receive the latest updates!

The September jobs report was surprisingly strong, as the U.S. economy added 254,000 net new jobs, far higher than forecasts.
4 minutes